Is it Really Unfair?
April 30, 2008 
Question: I have deep faith in Buddhism as a logical and systematic approach, almost philosophical, to life. But the other bits of it, the rebirth bits (where do we find proof? I know many people are said to be able to remember their past lives but perhaps they're just over imaginative? coincidental recounting of incidents that are taken as one's past life, or even schizophrenic people?), as well as the parts of being reborn in the Pure Land if one were to harbour pure thoughts while reciting Namo Amitabha - but how can it be fair to the poor man who spends his entire life reciting it well but nearing his death, loses concentration for a split second because of something beyond his control, e.g loud noise outside his hospital ward which is something beyond his control, thus, losing a wonderful chance to be reborn in the Pure Land, as opposed to someone who has never chanted Namo Amitabha and suddenly, converts to a Pure Land follower and goes to the Pure Land just before he dies? It's so unfair.
Response: First, those who can truly remember their past lives are extremely rare and have much good fortune. Others may be "over imaginative" as you said or perhaps unable to really tell what the "memories" are.
Second, those who are reborn in the Pure Land exhibit certain signs such as saying in advance when they will pass from this life, passing away without any sign of illness, passing away at will, remaining standing or sitting after passing. Or the body may remain flexible and maintain a good color many hours after death. The signs indicating rebirth are to be carefully checked and validated before being made public.
As for the conditions surrounding our death, we need to conserve our good fortune to create the right condition as we are dying. No other time is as important as this as our last moments lead us to our future rebirths. The person who suddenly encounters bad conditions, like that loud noise, did not have enough good fortune to ensure a peaceful, quiet environment.
And that person who hears of the Pure Land at the last moments and dies while chanting is unbelievably rare! We cannot count on that happening to us. This exceptional occurrence happens because the person was a practitioner in past lifetimes and conserved his good fortune in this lifetime. So he had the wonderful conditions to be conscious, to encounter a good spiritual advisor, to immediately and completely believe in the Pure Land, and to be able to practice, all while facing death. The coming together of all these conditions is unbelievably rare and the direct result of profound previous practice.
Reader Comments (4)
I would suggest at first look it may seem unfair but we may not be privy to the larger picture.
Many Pureland Practitioners tend to practice alone myself included and in so doing not have the information to hand that would show the true figures. Therefore it may be more common than we realize.
Blessings to You
Namo Amitabha Buddha
Dhammagevesi
Just to clarify for readers, people often perceive adverse conditions (like that sudden, distracting loud noise) as "unfair," but due to the workings of causality, everything is perfectly fair. It is due to people not yet knowing the causal connection that they deem such occurrences "unfair."
Since the original question had a few points in it, I apologize for not being absolutely sure which one you were addressing. So I'll take a guess and hope I'm general enough to address the one you had in mind. :-) While we do not know the exact figures as to how many people are reborn in the Pure Land or under what circumstances their rebirth occurred, it is very risky to believe we can wait till our last days to encounter all the right conditions for that good rebirth. It's far safer to not take chances and to do the practice on a regular basis as you are doing.
I am sorry I should have been more clear in my post Please forgive
It was in reference to the part of Your post where you say "The rebirth bits [where do we find prove]"
In Ven Master Thich Thien Tam's excellent book Buddhism of Wisdom and Faith
There is an explanation regarding Pure land Practitioners who are fortunate in obtaining rebirth in Sukhavati
There are physical signs that are not only apparent to the Practitioner but also to anyone who happens to be around at the time
Why this is not more widely known among Fellow Budhhists may be because Pure land Buddhists Especially in the West tend to practice alone or in small groups and tend not to publicise these experiences
While I have this opportunity
May I Thank You for all the Precious Teachings You have make available via the net They have been an eminence help in making progress One of the main reasons for me buying a computer and going on the net [In my sixtieth Year]
Blessings to You
Namo Amitabha Buddha
Dhammagevesi
Thank you for your additional comments. I agree that there are surely more rebirths into the Pure Land then we are aware of. Your point that people may not want to publicize what happened in a culture that is unfamiliar with the teachings is a good one. Trying to explain these phenomenon to people unfamiliar with them can be difficult as we don't want to create misunderstandings. And there are always those circumstances where people would not realize what the various rebirth phenomenon indicated.
Congratulations for joining the online community and even learning how to comment!
Amituofo